Is the New Castle, IN Metro Area Overvalued?

New Castle, IN home values are up 2.4% year-over-year

OpenRoof Score

Insufficient data

Not enough trustworthy data to score this market yet. OpenRoof Score requires coverage across multiple index dimensions.

Key Market Data — New Castle, IN

Median Home Value

202,627

Source: Zillow ZHVI

Home Value YoY

2

Source: Zillow ZHVI

Avg Monthly Rent

932

Source: Zillow ZORI

Rent YoY

2

Source: Zillow ZORI

Get the monthly housing market digest

Home value trends, fastest-moving markets, and key data points — free, once a month.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Data sources: Zillow ZHVI (home values, updated mid-month), Zillow ZORI (rent, updated mid-month), Realtor.com (inventory, days on market, updated 1st week of month), U.S. Census ACS (income, population, updated annually). Data as of April 2026.

Is the New Castle, IN Metro Overvalued? 2026 Price Analysis | OpenRoof | OpenRoof